Splash Magazines

Manon MetHD Review – Another Winner for Anna Netrebko

By Philip Hodge

View the Full Article | Return to the Site


Manon is an opera that grows on me.  I like it and appreciate it more every time I see it.  I’m sure I saw it in the years before I started writing opera reviews, but if I did, it did not make a lasting impression. 

Manon (Erina Newkirk) tries to hide her amusement at the attentions of Guillot (Michael Mendelsohn); photo by Robert Selinski

So when I saw the Pocket Opera production a year ago, it was like seeing it for the first time.  [To see my other reviews, click on SPLASH or OPERANUT, then type “manon” in the search box in the upper right corner].  I had mixed feelings about the opera per se  and about the performance of the opera.  I wrote a rather lengthy review, more than half of which was about the opera per se – and that part applies to this MetHD production without a single word change.  Rather than rewrite it  here or quote it at length, I am going to assume that you, the reader, have clicked on the above link and read that review as a preview of this one.  Okay?  Are you with me?

Manon (Anna Netrebko) as a teenager

According to Wikipedia, Anna Netrebko is over 40, married, and has a child.  But in Act I, she perfectly portrays Manon as a totally naïve teenager.  It is hard to not fall in love with her. 

Des Grieux (Piotr Beczala) professes his love for Manon (Anna Netrebko)

Likewise with Piotr Beczala who is a year or so older in real life and whose Chevalier des Grieux is barely 20.

Des Grieux (Piotr Beczala) tries in vain to overcome his infatuation with Manon (Anna Netrebko)

But oh, our Anna grew up in a hurry.  That’s no teenager who aborts des Grieux’ attempt to become a priest.

Des Grieux (Piotr Beczala) comforts the dying Manon (Anna Netrebko)

And she is oh-so-much older in the final tragic act.

Old man Guillot de Morfontaine (Christophe Mortagne) with his bevy of beautiful babes: Javotte (Jennifer Black), Rosette (Ginger Costa-Jackson), and Pousette(Anne-Carolyn Bird)

In this production, Christophe Mortagne’s interpretation of the role of Guillot de Morfontaine added to the disconnect between the various acts.  At the beginning he is played as a bumbling dotard.  This is good for a few cheap chuckles, but it is not consistent with his effective meanness in Act IV.  In contrast, Pocket Opera’s  Michael Mendelsohn played him straight as a dirty old man who knew perfectly well what he was buying with his money.

The Met staging was exceptionally effective in this production.  They made really imaginative use of the great height of the stage.  In the opening scene, street level is high up above the stage floor, but the inn courtyard where most of the action takes place is at floor-level.  Thus as each character enters the scene, he or she starts by descending a long flight of stairs along the back and one side wall – and when the two lovers leave they run up the steps to where Guillot’s coach is presumably waiting.

On the other hand, their little love nest in Paris is obviously a walk-up, and street level in on the basic stage.  Singers at today’s Met not only need a world-class voice and great acting ability; they also need strong legs!

Once again, I realize how lucky I am living now and on the Peninsula where on a Saturday I can go to a movie theater and see a grand large-scale opera with its enormous stage and all the hi-tech settings, its magnificient orchestra and chorus, its world-class singers in their fantastic costumes, and its frequent closeups so I can see the expressions on the singers’ faces.  Then on Sunday I can go to Pocket Opera or West Bay Opera and be part of a live audience watching a live performance from a seat close to the stage where the singers are young and pretty with voices that fill the small space with the same intensity that a world-class singer can fill the cavernous Lincoln Center auditorium.  As if that were not enough, I can go to War Memorial Hall and see San Francisco Opera and a visiting star such as Domingo, Fleming, or Voight along with a few thousand other people even if I’m a quarter-mile away from the stage.  And four times a year I go the the in-between sized Opera San Jose with some of advantages of both large and small, plus, since they are a resident company, I have the pleasure of seeing the same singer in many different roles.

Life doesn’t get any better than this!

The Metropolitan Opera

CinéArts at Palo Alto Square

Live in HD

3000 El Camino Real


Palo Alto, CA  94306

Photos, except as noted: Ken Howard/Metropolitan Opera

1-800-FANDANGO Exp Code 914#



Fabio Luisi

cast in order of vocal appearance


Guillot de Morfontaine

Christophe Mortagne

De Brétigny

Bradley Garvin


Anne-Carolyn Bird


Jennifer Black


Ginger Costa-Jackson

An Innkeeper

Philip Cokorinos

Lescaut, Manon’s cousin

Paulo Szot


Alexander Lewis


David Crawford

Manon Lescaut

Anna Netrebko

Chevalier des Grieux

Piotr Beczala

A Maid

Kathryn Day

Count des Grieux

David Pittsinger



Chorus Master

Donald Palumbo

Musical Preparation

Dennis Giauque


Donna Racik


Steven Eldredge


Denise Massé


Patrick Furrer

Assistant to the


Costume Designer

Jean-Jacques Delmotte

Assistant Stage Directors

Eric Einhorn


Gregory Keller


Tomer Zvulun

Stage Band Conductor

Jeffrey Goldberg


Donna Racik

Met Titles

Jacqueline Jones



Scenery, properties, and electrical props constructed

and painted by Royal Opera House Production Departments, Covent Garden, London; and Metropolitan Opera Shops

Costumes executed by          Royal Opera House Production Departments, Covent Garden, London;
                                           Thêátre du Capitole, Tolouse;
                                           Metropolitan Opera Costume Department
                                            Saint Laurie Merchant Tailors
                                            Studio Rouge
                                            Das Gewand Gmbh
Wigs by                                 Metropolitan Opera Wig Department






Published on Apr 20, 2012

View the Full Article | Return to the Site